Talk:Criticism of the Inheritance Cycle

From The Inheritance Encyclopedia

I don't think the comments about Arya wearing leather are entirely justified seeing as how you can make leather out of dead animals. Just a thought. -Henroast 13:19, 31 March 2007 (PDT)

That's like saying that they would be okay eating animals because they were dead animals. Since they can't eat dead animals, they probably wouldn't be able to wear them either.--Spiderchan 13:22, 14 April 2007 (PDT)

User opinions

Warning: This page or section is the opinion of the user-author only, and does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Shur'tugal and/or its staff members.

The problem with Paolini taking so much from so many other works, is that it's hard to tell what he wrote!

The problem arose when Paolini tried to write, and was actually led to believe that he could do so.

In Soviet Russia, YOU PLAGIARIZE PAOLINI!

I think his problem was e started his books too early, had he waited a few years more his books would've been more original and better plotted. But then one must consider he was a young boy when he began his story it was a very brave deed to publish a book at such a young age and to keep writing even though he is critized all over the world. It was just a young boy who didn't think twice that wrote this story.

True that he "borrowed" too many ideas. As one of my friends says, "CP? You mean 'Cheap Plagirism'?"